🍽
CRIMINAL DEFENSE LA
841% Increase in Local Search Visibility
+741%
Visibility Increase
83.47%
Keywords in Top 10
#3
Position Improvement
63
Months to Results
Client Overview
A criminal defense law firm in a mid-size market specializes in DUI/DWI defense, criminal justice, personal injury, and related legal services. The firm operates as a boutique practice with a strong track record and a perfect 5-star Google rating, backed by over 100 client reviews.
Despite an excellent reputation and deep local roots, the firm faced a critical visibility gap: potential clients searching for a DUI lawyer in the area were not finding them in Google's Local 3-Pack (the three listings that appear at the top of map-based search results and capture the vast majority of clicks).
The Challenge
When Tiger29 conducted the initial local search landscape scan in January, the firm's Google Business Profile performance revealed a competitive disadvantage:
Ranked #4 overall for the keyword "DUI lawyer" in their market—just outside the high-visibility Top 3 positions
Average Ranking Position (ARP) of 4.45—meaning across the entire geographic grid, they averaged nearly 5th place
Share of Local Voice (SoLV) of only 9.92%—out of 121 grid points scanned, the firm appeared in the Top 3 in fewer than 10% of locations
Three direct competitors dominated the local 3-pack, capturing nearly all visibility and inbound clicks
The Tiger29 Solution
Tiger29 implemented a targeted Google Business Profile optimization campaign between January and March, focusing on the signals Google uses to determine Local 3-Pack rankings: relevance, distance, and prominence. The strategy combined profile optimization with competitive positioning tactics designed to close the gap quickly.
Key Strategy Components:
Google Business Profile Audit & Optimization: Tiger29 conducted a comprehensive review of the firm's GBP profile, identifying gaps in category alignment, service descriptions, and keyword signals
Local Signal Enhancement: Tiger29 strengthened the website and online footprint to create better local authority signals through consistent NAP citations, optimized business description content, and strategic keyword integration
Competitive Landscape Analysis: A full 11x11 grid scan (121 data points) was executed across a 4-mile radius to map exactly where the firm appeared in local rankings
The Results: 63-Day Transformation
After just two months of focused GBP optimization, the impact on local search visibility was dramatic. The March benchmark scan revealed transformational improvements across every key metric.
METRIC
JANUARY
MARCH
CHANGE
Share of Local Voice
9.92%
83.47%
Average Ranking Position
4.45
3.31
Overall Market Position
#4
#3
Grid Coverage
100%
100%
-1.14 (Better)
+1 Position
Maintained (All 121 Points)
Google Rating
5.0
5.0
Maintained
Key Achievements
+741%
What This Means for the Business
For any law firm, the local 3-pack is the highest-value real estate in Google search. Studies consistently show that the top three map results capture the overwhelming majority of clicks for high-intent searches like "DUI lawyer near me."
A Share of Local Voice of 83.47% means that in 83 out of every 100 local searches across the service area, this firm now appears in the most prominent position on the page.
Before Tiger29's optimization, the firm was essentially invisible in most searches despite having a perfect 5-star rating. A 9.92% SoLV meant that only 1 in 10 potential clients even had a chance to see their listing. After just two months, that ratio flipped dramatically.
The results represent a fundamental shift in how often the firm appears in front of people who need their services. More appearances in the 3-pack means more calls, more consultations, and more cases.
Conclusion
In just 63 days, Tiger29's targeted GBP optimization campaign transformed this law firm's local search presence from a fringe competitor to a dominant local voice. The 741% increase in Share of Local Voice is a direct result of strategic, data-driven optimization—not luck or timing.
This case study demonstrates that even businesses with excellent reputations and strong review profiles can be significantly under-served by an unoptimized Google Business Profile. With the right approach, the gap between a great business and a highly visible one can be closed faster than most people expect.
SoLV surged from 9.92% to 83.47% — a 741% increase in the firm's footprint across the local search grid
Average Ranking Position improved from 4.45 to 3.31 — breaking consistently into Top 3 territory across the market
Moved from #4 to #3 overall in the competitive local landscape, overtaking a multi-practice firm that had held a top position
Maintained 100% grid visibility across all 121 scan points—the firm appeared in local results for every search point within the 4-mile radius
Two major competitors saw SoLV remain stagnant or decline — confirming that the firm's gains came directly at their expense
Competitive Landscape: Before vs. After
Despite a 5-star Google rating and 117 reviews, the profile was not being surfaced to the majority of nearby searchers
The firm's goal: Break into consistent Top 3 rankings across their service area and capture the click-through rates that come with Local 3-Pack placement.
The scan data shows the firm's rise was not incidental—it was driven by sustained optimization that directly displaced competitors in the Local 3-Pack.
BUSINESS
ARP JAN
ARP MAR
SOLV OUTCOME
Competitor A (Criminal Justice Atty)
1.92
2.23
Competitor B (Attorney/Multi-practice)
1.40
Not in top 3
Competitor C (Criminal Justice Atty)
3.12
1.36
Client ★
4.45
3.31
Dropped out
Improved
+741% SoLV
While Competitor C (a criminal justice attorney) improved their ARP, the client's dramatic SoLV gain to 83.47% demonstrates that raw ARP improvements don't tell the full story. Share of Local Voice, which measures consistent Top 3 presence across the geographic grid, is the metric that translates to real-world phone calls and leads.
Dropped
Ready to Get Similar Results?
See how Tiger29's data-driven SEO strategies can help your business dominate local search and drive real revenue growth.